By David Kane
“We are not what you’re used to. We don’t have the same ideas or goals as the artists that you see on MTV,” reminisces rapper/producer El-P about his late-’90s group Company Flow—and his subsequent Def Jux roster. The turn of the century saw shiny, polished mainstream hip-hop soaring to new heights, and El and his cohorts took to the underground, fighting that tide with grimy sounds and authentic energy. “When you’re not worried about making money, when that’s not even an option, you have no problem going absolutely batshit crazy on your records, because why the fuck not?”
I’m speaking with El-P (short for El Producto) in April 2022 shortly before rehearsals for his performance at the twice-delayed Coachella festival in California. He will be performing alongside Killer Mike in their all-conquering duo Run the Jewels, an indie rap behemoth that has defied age and expectation in becoming one of the most loved (and booked) groups on the festival circuit. But we’re not here to talk about them; instead, we rewind the clock twenty years, focusing on the making and release of his first solo album: 2002’s Fantastic Damage.
Born Jaime Meline, El-P’s origin story is well established by this point, but he came to prominence via Company Flow alongside Bigg Jus and their DJ, Mr. Len. Musically, the New Yorkers were an urgent shot in the arm for hip-hop—a dense, cerebral, and verbose lyrical assault over hard drums and esoteric samples in a glorious blurring of science and fiction. Or, to put it simply, “batshit crazy…records.”
Early singles like “Juvenile Techniques” and “8 Steps to Perfection” were well received, with DJ Stretch Armstrong and Bobbito Garcia championing Company Flow on their eponymous radio show. They were spinning their earliest demo recordings, many of which would wind up on the group’s self-released 1995 EP, Funcrusher. A new era for hip-hop was emerging from a community that couldn’t relate to the mainstream. As El recalls, “In the mid- and late ’90s, I think it felt like there were two different worlds: You were either sort of out there in public and you were successful in videos—you were on a major label and were making music that was exposed—or you were part of the scene of people we were a part of. When it first started, it was just a scene of artists. And it was just a cultural thing that was bubbling underneath [the mainstream] that there was no mechanism for anyone to have a career yet. So we were all sort of just doing it for each other.”
Company Flow was at the epicenter of this scene, and in 1997 they were ready to release their debut album, Funcrusher Plus, an extended version of the EP. The red-hot heat surrounding the record resulted in a bidding war from labels, with the nascent Rawkus eventually winning. The indie label was founded by Brian Brater and Jarret Myer, with financial backing by friend James Murdoch, son of media overlord Rupert, who eventually bought a majority stake in the label.

Company Flow (Bigg Jus, Mr. Len, and El-P) on the Brooklyn Bridge, September 1997. Photo by Catherine McGann/Getty Images.
Despite the incongruity of it all now, Rawkus released some excellent records and represented the vanguard of independent hip-hop. “The Def [Jux] label sprung out of that ethos,” explains El-P. “I think Rawkus was the precursor to that. But I think that they quickly intended to move into a different realm.”
Whereas Rawkus proved a musical launchpad for artists—releasing classic debut albums by Mos Def, Talib Kweli, Pharoahe Monch, and zeitgeist compilations like the Soundbombing and Lyricist Lounge series—Def Jux evolved the independent ethos into a social movement.
Infamously, the relationship between Company Flow and Rawkus broke down after a lack of support for the group’s second album. After Bigg Jus decided to leave the group, “Me and Len did Little Johnny from the Hospitul: Breaks End Instrumentuls Vol.1,” says El. “It was an instrumental record, which is exactly not what the label wanted us to do.” El-P has long since “made peace with the Rawkus thing,” he says. “But when I was young, I was, you know, fiercely idealistic and pissed off at pretty much everything that rubbed me wrong.”
Which brings us to the second record that has come to define El Producto 1.0: The Cold Vein, the debut album by Cannibal Ox, a duo comprised of the Harlem-based MCs Vast Aire and Vordul Mega. Produced in its entirety by El-P, 2001’s The Cold Vein was the first full-length release on his Def Jux label. Cannibal Ox and El-P created a sublimely gritty document of the Big Apple gone rotten, where people live no better than pigeons, preyed upon by politicians, vultures, and swarming rats. Like the Bat Signal slicing through the darkness of night in Gotham, The Cold Vein was both a call to arms and a warning sign: the wheels of succession in hip-hop were in motion once more. The Rawkus era had come to pass; this was the dawn of Def Jux.
However, in the same year, 2001, El was forced to change the name of the label to Definitive Jux after Russell Simmons and Def Jam sued him over the similarities in the name. They eventually settled out of court, and the story was immortalized on “Dead Disnee”: “Rush said he didn’t like the name / Try to tell me that my peoples aren’t def?” The original pressing of Fantastic Damage also includes a deliberately conspicuous Definitive Jux logo on the cover for posterity.
“Vordul and Vast were living in my apartment,” El-P says of the genesis of The Cold Vein. “They [both] shared a room with mattresses on the floor. I was working on their record, and the studio was in another room. My bedroom was upstairs, and the whole [independent rap] scene was constantly filing through the house. And it was kind of mayhem, but it was a creative time, and everybody was just sort of there and supporting each other. The guy with the adjoining wall [was] desperately banging on the wall, like four in the morning, like, ‘Please let me sleep!’ And us, just being assholes about it, we just didn’t care. And I had to be young; it was just constant energy. And that was one of the great things about the Def Jux era.”
Uncommon Nasa, the in-house engineer for Definitive Jux (who also contributes a few bars on Fantastic Damage’s “Constellation Funk”) expands on the memory: “I think what was so endearing about the music that was created at that time is everyday working-class rappers and producers were doing it. Our surroundings didn’t look much different than any other early twenties–aged flophouse apartment, with piles of dirty laundry lining the hallways, stacks of dirty dishes piled up next to an empty fridge, and of course, every table had a glass filled with water that empty cigarette butts would accumulate inside of. There was zero luxury to that time for any of us as we all found our way into who we’d become as full-grown adults. We just happened to all cross paths to create some classic music together.”
Despite the dishes and piles of laundry, there was a “pretty legit system packed into those apartments,” according to Nasa. The setup for Fantastic Damage included “a Mackie D8B board to mix with. It was recorded on a RØDE NT1 [mic], and El made all the arrangements in Pro Tools. We recorded to ADATs in those days, though, so we were striping back and forth between Pro Tools and the decks,” he says of recording individual stems. “Mixes were sent down to DATs. The technology we were using was very much of its era, that awkward time before an entire session might end up ‘in the box’ but after reel-to-reel tape recording.”
Partly thanks to his work on Little Johnny from the Hospitul, El-P was finding new details in sound as well as a better overall picture of song construction and atmosphere. “I wanted Cold Vein to feel very cold,” El says. “It felt like a train ride through New York City in the winter. And I needed Fantastic Damage to sound like liquid magma, dripping off a building. It needed to be warm and a little more punk. It was a lot more layered and chaotic. The songs changed and [metamorphosed], and I started paying more attention to structure and what you can do in a song,” while remaining as “hip-hop as you fucking got.”
After the critical acclaim of the Company Flow and Cannibal Ox albums, El-P could have easily carved a lane for himself as a producer for hire, outside of his work as a trio, if it wasn’t for the butterfly effect of Bigg Jus leaving Co Flow and Mr. Len following not long after. That forced him to reassess things: “We launched Def Jux with new Company Flow songs and with Cannibal Ox songs, sort of an A/B-side thing. But then Len said it didn’t feel right to him and wanted to do something else. And it was heartbreaking to me, because I didn’t want to let [Company Flow] die. I was like, ‘Well, I’m certainly not going to stop. I just got started, you know?’ And so I better figure it out quickly. What my voice is in that context. And I think that’s what Fantastic Damage was.

El-P with Company Flow at the Jazz Cafe, London, circa 1997. Photo by Brigitte Engl/Redferns.
“It was the first time I did a record that mined a bit of my history and life,” El-P continues. “For the most part, Company Flow was just us having a lot of fun just as wordsmiths and throwing a lot of different concepts and ideas out there. But it wasn’t a particularly personal thing. I had to think, ‘Well, what does this mean now that I’m being forced to be a solo artist? What do I have to say?’ And so I just went inward, I think, a bit more than I ever have. And that was the beginning of me exploring what I could say on my own, and sort of everything I could think of I threw at that thing.”
But that seed started with Company Flow, and the track “Last Good Sleep,” which addresses the relationship with his abusive stepfather, who nearly beat his mother to death. “I was hesitant to put that song on the Funcrusher [Plus] album,” he says. “Me and Jus had decided to write a song each about something a little bit more personal. And I went off into a corner, and he went off in his corner. He made [“Lune TNS”] about his love for graffiti and growing up and bombing. And I ended up writing something that I had attempted to write a few times but never really went there because it was painful and was still fresh for me to some degree.
“But we put it on the record, and the response I got from that song was tangible and beautiful,” says El. “And people started coming up to me with tears in their eyes. And that opened my eyes as an artist. And so I got addicted to that aspect of writing as well. And, to some degree, [it] eradicated a lot of that trauma I had been carrying. It just opened my eyes to what could be done with writing. So when I went into Fantastic Damage, I was way less hesitant to expose myself.”
What had started with “Last Good Sleep” matured in Fantastic Damage, and El’s writing had leveled up. There was still the intensity, the many bars per minute, the Brooklyn kid too smart for his own good, but there was also a newfound depth. El-P had crossed the Rubicon.
In “Stepfather Factory,” he could fuse the personal and the political—his distrust of institutions, consumerism, and his trauma. It’s a humdinger of a concept track that he approaches with just enough distance to inject “a little bit of gallows humor to the whole thing and being able to look at it and discuss it from a philosophical perspective. I just thought it was darkly funny that if you were to go to the future [and] we were to create robotic stepfathers, they would still get drunk and beat your mother up,” says El-P. “I had had a lot of time to think about our family. Recognizing that the reason why so many women, mothers specifically, would let people into their lives and their child’s lives is to try and fix what they believe is [broken and make] the correct family unit.
“And I think that what happened in my family, at least, is that my mother’s standards…kind of got a little bit diluted,” he says. “Through guilt, stress, and the idea of not wanting to be alone in this challenge of raising children, sometimes a Trojan horse can slip in through the ranks. It’s about the idea of wanting to make something whole; maybe you’re cramming material in there that won’t hold, and ultimately it ends up being just as damaging, if not more damaging.
“And it seemed like the idea of the future and a robot just being a perfect metaphor,” he explains. “And that’s why I’m a big science fiction fan and avid reader. It’s a mechanism to talk about the truth through an extreme metaphor. And so, therefore, with the release of the constraints of factuality and reality, you get to home in on some truth that wasn’t available to you if you only tried to keep it grounded in current reality. So I could think about it in a little bit more detached and writerly way.”
El’s writing evolution was making an impression on others, such as Aesop Rock, who was just beginning his journey with Def Jux and appears on the cocky posse cut “Delorean” alongside Ill Bill and El in a celebration of “out-there pop culture references.”
“I was young and completely enamored by all of it,” Aesop Rock explains to me. “I hadn’t heard anyone rhyme the way El does, and even in those later Co Flow songs, you could tell he was tapping into something extra. He was always a maniac with the writing, and being around while he was figuring out what it means to be ‘El-P solo’ was really special. I think he had a bunch of moments throughout the making of Fantastic Damage where he saw himself do something new. Beat-wise too. Just those ‘Oh, there’s more’ moments. I know he felt that way about ‘Stepfather Factory’—just that it was new ground. And those are the moments he needed. No label, no group, just him doing his thing, realizing there’s still a ton of creative doors to open.”
Another song to benefit from the newfound heft of El’s pen was “Dead Disnee,” a result of his ongoing fascination with corporate America’s attempts “to project an alternate reality based on some sort of bullshit morality and the idea of what society is supposed to be.” According to El, “The Disney thing was just a mechanism that I stumbled on to make a point about the truth of our country, which is dirty and fucked up and nothing like Disney World. And it was just a really cool excuse to riff on that.”
It’s on “Dead Disnee” where things get a little weird, and an unexpected, and unwanted, narrative becomes entwined with Fantastic Damage, an album that was a year and a half in the making. “About ninety-five percent of the record was made prior to 9/11,” says El-P. By the time the album was released in May 2002, the world was a markedly different place. The events of September 11 colored lyrics like “When the city burns down, I’m gonna go to Disney World” and the album’s broader, dystopian themes with an eerie sense of foresight. Especially, says El, “when the city did burn down in front of my eyes.” “That was one of the first times I was like, ‘That’s weird. That’s eerie. I know I didn’t write this after 9/11.’ I felt uncomfortable about it. I was like, ‘Should I change that?’ And I was like, ‘You know what? Fuck that shit. I’m not going to change it.’ I think that the interesting thing about that is that people assign music to emotions they’re dealing with at the moment. And I get it.
“The reason why it bothered me that people were always assigning it to be a post-9/11 record is simply that these ideas were created prior to 9/11,” El explains. “And I think that was one of my big gripes with our country and with our world. [I] was like, look, if you guys had seen this before 9/11, maybe 9/11 wouldn’t have fucking happened. If we were thinking on these terms, if we saw through the veil, if we were discussing the actual gritty underbelly of the truth of America and the Western world, and the way that we are dealing with life and society, then maybe, maybe we could have avoided a 9/11. And so it did sort of bother me, because in my mind, it was like the truth has been there. It’s been right in front of you. And if not the truth, then the questions at least have been there, you know.”
Uncommon Nasa builds on the notion: “This isn’t a political record to me as much as it’s a record that represents El’s perspective on his prior life experiences. I think this is shown throughout the record but starts famously on ‘Squeegee Man Shooting.’ It was a dark period, and even before 9/11, many of us were concerned about the fledgling George W. Bush presidency and how he was awarded that title. Ultimately, I’d say that El was making a personalized album during a very dark period in the United States. So I wouldn’t say this is a post-9/11 record at all, but I would say that this record is representative of the period of 9/11 in America.”
In preparation for this interview, I went down the bunny hole on Fantastic Damage. I was struck by specific phrases and lyrics like “internet wars” (from “Dead Disnee”) and seeing “phones with ceaseless animatronics / pager buttons rusted in the on position” (from “Constellation Funk”) that El wrote more than twenty years ago. In an age of “alternative facts” and a society obsessed with smartphones, I put it to El, half-jokingly, that he might be a shaman.
“No. I am a shamed man,” he says with a laugh. “I’ve been weirded out several times by this weird sort of pattern of shit that I’m saying, somehow seeming like it’s becoming true. But I do believe that in writing, symbolism and metaphor are just as powerful, if not more powerful than specific treatises and ideas. And if you’re engaging in some symbolism, you can predict the future because the future is only the result of the present.
“And I think that’s one of the reasons I’ve always chosen more of an impressionistic way of writing, because those [predictions for the future] tend to apply if you’re empathetic about it,” says El. “So, often I’m like, ‘Why haven’t I been writing about me being a billionaire?’ You know, I spent so much time writing about how the world is going to be horrible and now it is. I could have focused my energy on something a little bit more self-centered, like, ‘I’m going to have a boat.’”
Perhaps these are all just cosmic coincidences (of which there are many more), or the traits that mark out artists and their preternatural gifts from the rest of us. Whatever it is, it’s a reminder that great art isn’t just timeless, it is prescient too.
--------
Read it in print: “Chaos and Catharsis” first ran in Wax Poetics Vol. 2, Issue 4, alongside Don Cherry, Roxy Music, Steely Dan, and our drum machine special.
--------




“This is a journey into sound”: The history of Ministry of Sound’s speaker stacks
RE:DISCOVERY